Skip to main content
European Commission logo

Total benefit - Benefit-cost-ratio of standard interventions for road Maintenance (VSS2004/714)

Switzerland Flag
Complete with results
Geo-spatial type
Project website
STRIA Roadmaps
Network and traffic management systems (NTM)
Transport mode
Road icon
Transport policies
Societal/Economic issues
Transport sectors
Passenger transport,
Freight transport


Background & Policy context

The systematic planning of interventions is a central and crucial process within the management of road maintenance. It determines the type and time of interventions to be performed
in order to attain the best benefit-cost ratio. The foundation and instruments to be used for this planning, and the determination of the optimal interventions, is provided for Switzerland
by the individual projects in research package VSS 2004/710-716. 


Establishment of methods and benchmarks for the comprehensive determination of monetary benefits for standard maintenance interventions on roads, for application in the cost-benefit analysis.


Following steps will be provided during the project:

  • Evaluating existing effect models
  • Correlation analysis of road conditions, maintenance expenses, travel behavior and accident rates on selected national road sections
  • Definition and test of KNA-valuation models for defined application examples and conservation measures
  • Workshops with the Advisory Group and interested parties


Parent Programmes
Institution Type
Public institution
Institution Name
Swiss Government: State Secretariat for Education and Research
Type of funding
Public (national/regional/local)


The interventions considered in Project 4 were preservation interventions, i.e. interventions that restore the condition of a road section up to but not beyond its original condition, and are
performed when the condition of a road section, normally assessed through the surface condition of the pavement, reaches a specified threshold. The resulting changes in routine maintenance
interventions, i.e. small local interventions were considered as a (positive or negative) benefit of the intervention with respect to a reference case. Small local interventions, such as crack and pothole filling, are required to prevent the unnecessary acceleration of deterioration processes and unnecessary decreases in safety, but do not improve the condition of a road section, and are performed when it is not desired, or in waiting, to perform a preservation intervention.

In the results proposed in project 4, it is considered that the benefits of interventions can be attributed to the operator, user or the public. The main benefit of the operator is seen as the reduction of maintenance costs, e.g. the performing of a preservation intervention today can reduce the cost of routine maintenance in the coming years, while always providing an adequate level of service. The benefits of the users are seen as the reduction of travel time, discomfort, vehicle operating costs, and accident costs. The benefits of the public are seen as the reduction of accident costs and environmental costs, including noise, air pollution and climate costs.

It is proposed that the benefits be considered to be the positive difference between the costs incurred with performing an intervention, including the temporary perturbations to traffic flow, when compared with not performing that intervention, while a reference intervention strategy is being followed over a certain period of time.


Lead Organisation
EU Contribution
Partner Organisations
EU Contribution


Contribute! Submit your project

Do you wish to submit a project or a programme? Head over to the Contribute page, login and follow the process!