Skip to main content
European Commission logo
TRIMIS

Reduction potential of external costs of motorized individual mobility by the promotional programme VEL 2 in the Canton Ticino

Project

SVI 2001/535 - Reduction potential of external costs of motorized individual mobility by the promotional programme VEL 2 in the Canton Ticino


Funding origin:
Switzerland
Switzerland
STRIA Roadmaps:
Transport electrification (ELT)
Transport electrification
Transport mode:
Road
Road
Transport sectors:
Passenger transport
Passenger transport
Freight transport
Freight transport
Micromobility
Micromobility
Duration:
Start date: 01/06/2003,
End date: 01/01/2006

Status: Finished
Funding details:

Overview

Background & policy context:

In modern societies spatial mobility of persons and goods has gained an undeniable importance. It also is one of the human activities with the highest effects on the environment and the most important single factor of anthropogenic climate change. The emissions caused by traffic also affect human health and buildings and ecosystems get badly damaged. Reducing negative traffic impacts is a difficult political task as well as a tremendous social challenge.

Different economic analyses give a rough idea of the extent of economic costs as due to traffic which ensue for the population of Switzerland. Recent studies assert annual costs of about 5 billions CHF a year caused by terrestrial traffic on road and rail alone. The most important fields regard health costs caused by airborne emissions and noise, by accident and damages on buildings and ecosystems. This account however does not include either the consequences of putative climate changes or infrastructure costs. In fact all these costs are not covered by those who caused them and they are therefore called external costs. For years welfare economists have been pleading for the application of the "polluter pays principle" of internalisation of external costs, in order to reduce traffic volume and environmental impact on a socially optimal level.

The promoting of efficient and alternative engines is a further option for the reduction of environmental impact caused by traffic. These measures have a considerable reducing potential with respect to negative traffic impacts, because they do not interfere with habits and mobility patterns. In mid 1995 a pilot and demonstration project (VEL1) was started in Mendrisio (a town in the Canton of Ticino). The scope of this project was to promote and test electrical light vehicles in everyday traffic conditions. In 2001 this project was expanded in two directions; hence including efficient vehicles with less than 120g of CO2-emissions per kilometre as well as being extended over the whole region of the Canton Tessin (VEL2).

Several technical, social and mobility-related aspects of this programme have been investigated in detail, so far. The present study is focused on the external costs of motorised individual mobility and the possibilities of reducing them by efficient vehicles, electric vehicles and electric scooters.

Objectives:

The goal of this study was to quantify the external costs, which can be saved by energy efficient and environmentally friendly vehicles in the realm of the VEL2 promotion programme in the Ticino canton (VEL2 programme: promotion of electrical lightweight vehicles and efficient fuel driven cars).

The study aimed to show the relationship between external and private costs, which is important in order to offer to the consumer a comprehensive basis to make his choice.

Besides the analysis of existing studies on external costs and the examination of different calculation approaches the study has to evaluate the significance of the approach of internalisation of external costs in the environmental and transportation debate.

In particular, the study examined the relevance of the external costs for the proposed bonus malus system of the succeeding programme VEL 3. This includes the analysis of the opinion of various stakeholders. The project concludes with some policy recommendations.

Methodology:

The project started with an analysis of the existing studies on external costs and evaluates the possibilities to apply them to the present example. On this basis those approaches are chosen, which seem to fit best to the conditions of Ticino.

The project presents estimates of the external as well as private costs per vehicle and unit of driven distances, in order to offer to the consumer a comprehensive basis to compare the different cost components of individual mobility. Furthermore, the significance of the internalisation of external costs in the environmental debate is discussed with different stakeholders. Finally, the results of these discussions are included in the conclusion concerning the integration of external costs for the proposed bonus malus system and are used to formulate policy recommendations for the succeeding programme VEL 3.

Contribute! Submit your project

Do you wish to submit a project or a programme? Head over to the Contribute page, login and follow the process!

Submit