Skip to main content
TRIMIS

VALidation and Improvement of Airframe Noise prediction Tools

PROJECTS
Funding
European
European Union
Duration
-
Status
Complete with results
Geo-spatial type
Other
Total project cost
€3 721 683
EU Contribution
€2 700 000
Project website
Project Acronym
VALIANT
Transport mode
Airborne icon
Transport policies
Environmental/Emissions aspects
Transport sectors
Passenger transport,
Freight transport

Overview

Call for proposal
FP7-AAT-2008-RTD-1
Link to CORDIS
Background & Policy context

The overall noise radiated by modern aircraft has two sources: the engine and the airframe. The airframe noise has a broadband character and is mainly due to the interaction of the turbulent airflow with high lift devices (slats and flaps) and landing gears. And to a second extent to cavities, spoilers and boundary layers developing along the fuselage.

One of the major ACARE objectives was the reduction of perceived noise level of fixed-wing aircraft by 50% by 2020 compared to 2001. In achieving this, reduction of airframe noise is very important especially for large aircraft, as the development of quieter engines continues.

Objectives

The focus of the project was on broadband noise generated by the turbulent flow around the airframe, as it is one of the most important components of aircraft generated acoustic nuisances. Its prediction and subsequent reduction was essential for achieving the ACARE2020 objectives of noise level reductions.

However, the complexity and diversity of broadband turbulent noise sources makes that prediction with present numerical tools extremely challenging and far from mature.

The objectives of the VALIANT project were to generate new experimental data and to validate and improve numerical tools for prediction of airframe noise generated from landing gears, slats, flaps and local separation regions.

Methodology

The VALIANT project was an upstream research-oriented project, with the objective to tackle this challenge by generating new experimental data and validating and improving numerical tools for prediction of airframe noise generated from landing gears, slats, flaps and local separation regions.

Due to the extremely complex physical nature of the phenomenon and the high computational cost of computing full aircraft configurations on the one hand, and a lack of a reliable experimental database on the other hand, VALIANT focused on key generic test cases representing the major broadband airframe noise mechanisms associated with multiple body interactions: flow past two-struts (landing gear), flow past air foil with flap, flow past air foil with slat and turbulent flow past a gap. For all these configurations, the components of the noise prediction chain (for turbulent/source region, near- and far-field propagation domains) and their mutual interactions are evaluated and avenues of improvement developed.

It was expected that by validating and improving the predictive tools, a deeper insight into the mechanisms behind airframe noise would be obtained, which is an essential step towards new efficient airframe noise reduction concepts and their optimisation to achieve the required breakthrough towards quieter aircraft.

The consortium was formed by 12 European and Russian partners: 2 universities and 7 research establishments including the most important technology providers to the airframe industry, and 3 companies (2 SMEs) providing dedicated engineering services and software tools in aero acoustics to transport industries with emphasis on aeronautics.

Funding

Parent Programmes
Institution Type
Public institution
Institution Name
The European Commission
Type of funding
Public (EU)
Specific funding programme
FP7-TRANSPORT

Results

  • Provision of a benchmark database for the computations.
  • Obtaining more insight in the basic noise generation mechanisms which enabled enable a thorough assessment of the numerical results NLR performed both far-field and microphone array measurements in order to determine the noise directivity and the source localisation for different regimes of speeds and angles of attack of the two-struts alignment.

Besides these acoustic measurements NLR obtained pressure data on the surfaces of the struts and VKI performed PIV measurements.

CIMNE, IMM, NUMECA and TUB performed numerical simulations on three distinct configurations of this test case, while NLR has been leading the experimental campaign. CIMNE has performed CFD simulations using a variational multi-scale technique. The inhomogeneous Helmholtz equation has been solved to compute the acoustic pressure in the far-field. IMM uses a hybrid Detached Eddy Simulation (DES) method for the numerical representation of the compressible viscous flow while the aeroacoustic analysis is based on the FW-H formulation. NUMECA has performed LES simulations and completed the aeroacoustic analysis based on the FW-H formulation. TUB performed the CFD simulations using a DDES technique and completed the aeroacoustic analysis based on the FW-H formulation.

Near-field and far-field results obtained by the different numerical partners have been extensively compared with experimental data. The computed time-averaged flow-fields are overall in good agreement with the experimental data. The discrepancies that are observed for some quantities (i.e. Cp values on the downstream side of the second strut, turbulent intensities between the two struts for the inclined configurations) are similar for all LES-based results (IMM, NUMECA TUB).

The same post-processing approach has been used to evaluate near-field and far-field spectra from unsteady pressure signals. The dominant peaks in the solid-wall spectra are well captured for both struts with maximum discrepancies of about 5 dB in level and about 20 Hz in frequency.
Again, the same discrepancies with respect to the experimental data are generally observed for all LES-based results. Since the simulated spanwise length is not the same as in the experiments, a correction had to be applied to the computed far-field noise. This correction allows for some freedom in the choice of the numerical values for certain parameters. Even though more uncertainties are added through this correcti

Strategy targets

  • Innovating for the future: technology and behaviour - A European Transport Research and Innovation Policy

Partners

Lead Organisation
Organisation
Institut Von Karman De Dynamique Des Fluides
Address
Chaussee De Waterloo 72, 1640 Rhode Saint Genese, Belgium
EU Contribution
€512 224
Partner Organisations
Organisation
New Technologies And Services
Address
Dobrolyubov Ave., 14, SAINT-PETERSBURG, 197198, Russia
EU Contribution
€1 491 927
Organisation
New Technologies And Services
Address
Dobrolyubov Ave., 14, SAINT-PETERSBURG, 197198, Russia
EU Contribution
€166 647
Organisation
Keldysh Institute Of Applied Mathematics Of The Russian Academy Of Sciences
Address
Miusskaya Pl., 4, Moscow, 125047, Russia
EU Contribution
€996 875
Organisation
Keldysh Institute Of Applied Mathematics Of The Russian Academy Of Sciences
Address
Miusskaya Pl., 4, Moscow, 125047, Russia
EU Contribution
€135 000
Organisation
Institute For Mathematical Modelling Of Russian Academy Of Sciences
Address
MIUSSKAYA SQ. 4A, MOSCOW, 125047, Russia
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€1 999 985
Organisation
Institute For Mathematical Modelling Of Russian Academy Of Sciences
Address
MIUSSKAYA SQ. 4A, MOSCOW, 125047, Russia
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€0
Organisation
Stichting Centrum Voor De Ontwikkeling Van Transport En Logistiek In Europa
Address
Van Nelleweg 1, 3044 BC Rotterdam, Netherlands
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€7 787 411
Organisation
Stichting Centrum Voor De Ontwikkeling Van Transport En Logistiek In Europa
Address
Van Nelleweg 1, 3044 BC Rotterdam, Netherlands
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€176 813
Organisation
Technische Universitat Berlin
Address
STRASSE DES 17 JUNI 135, 10623 Berlin, Germany
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€2 799 391
Organisation
Technische Universitat Berlin
Address
STRASSE DES 17 JUNI 135, 10623 Berlin, Germany
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€224 414
Organisation
Office National D' Etudes Et De Recherches Aérospatiales
Address
29, avenue de la Division Leclerc, BP72 CHÂTILLON CEDEX, France
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€5 057 658
Organisation
Office National D' Etudes Et De Recherches Aérospatiales
Address
29, avenue de la Division Leclerc, BP72 CHÂTILLON CEDEX, France
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€315 503
Organisation
Deutsches Zentrum Fr Luft Und Raumfahrt E.v
Address
Linder Hoehe, 51147 KOELN, Germany
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€691 910
Organisation
Deutsches Zentrum Fr Luft Und Raumfahrt E.v
Address
Linder Hoehe, 51147 KOELN, Germany
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€272 213
Organisation
Siemens Industry Software Nv
Address
INTERLEUVENLAAN 68, 3001 LEUVEN, Belgium
EU Contribution
€3 281 750
Organisation
Siemens Industry Software Nv
Address
INTERLEUVENLAAN 68, 3001 LEUVEN, Belgium
EU Contribution
€171 496
Organisation
Federal State Unitary Enterprise Aerohydrodynamic Institute
Address
1, Zhykovsky str., ZHUKOVSKY, MOSCOW REG, 140180, Russia
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€8 480 813
Organisation
Federal State Unitary Enterprise Aerohydrodynamic Institute
Address
1, Zhykovsky str., ZHUKOVSKY, MOSCOW REG, 140180, Russia
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€131 813
Organisation
Ecole Centrale De Lyon
Address
AVENUE GUY DE COLLONGUE 36, 69134 ECULLY, France
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€18 273 829
Organisation
Ecole Centrale De Lyon
Address
AVENUE GUY DE COLLONGUE 36, 69134 ECULLY, France
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€171 446
Organisation
Centre Internacional De Metodes Numerics En Enginyeria
Address
C Gran Capitan, Edifici C1, Campus Nord Upc Sn, 8034 Barcelona, Spain
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€1 500 000
Organisation
Centre Internacional De Metodes Numerics En Enginyeria
Address
C Gran Capitan, Edifici C1, Campus Nord Upc Sn, 8034 Barcelona, Spain
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€168 998
Organisation
Numerical Mechanics Application International
Address
5 Avenue Franklin Roosevelt, 1050 BRUSSELS, Belgium
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€3 837 129
Organisation
Numerical Mechanics Application International
Address
5 Avenue Franklin Roosevelt, 1050 BRUSSELS, Belgium
Organisation website
EU Contribution
€253 434

Technologies

Technology Theme
Aircraft noise reduction at source"
Technology
Aircraft noise reduction at source"
Development phase
Research/Invention

Contribute! Submit your project

Do you wish to submit a project or a programme? Head over to the Contribute page, login and follow the process!

Submit